Tax

What a marginal rate actually means

A raise cannot leave you worse off. The rate on the next pound is not the rate on all of them...

Hands working through a tax form with a calculator
Hands working through a tax form with a calculator

The most common tax mistake is believing that crossing into a higher band raises the tax on everything you earn. It does not, and the belief costs people real money when they turn down overtime or a raise to avoid it.

Bands are steps, not cliffs

Income tax works in slices. The first slice is taxed at nothing, the next at a basic rate, the next at a higher rate, and so on. When your income crosses a threshold, only the part above the threshold is taxed at the new rate. The slices below it are untouched.

A worked example

Suppose the basic rate is twenty percent up to 50,000 and forty percent above it. Someone earning 49,000 pays twenty percent on their taxable income. Someone earning 51,000 pays twenty percent on the first 50,000 and forty percent on the last 1,000, which is 400 rather than 200. They keep 600 of the extra 2,000. They are better off, just by less than they expected.

Where cliffs do exist

Some benefits and allowances are withdrawn all at once above a threshold rather than tapered, and there the effective rate on a single pound can be far higher than any headline band. These are worth knowing about and are listed in the questions below. They are the exception, and they are about withdrawal, not about the tax bands themselves.

The number to know

Your marginal rate: what you keep of the next pound. It decides whether overtime is worth it, whether a pension contribution is cheap, and whether a raise is as big as it looks. It is almost never the number on your payslip.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a raise ever leave me worse off?
Not through the income tax bands themselves. It can through a benefit or allowance that is withdrawn in full above a threshold, which is a cliff rather than a step. Check whether you are near one before you turn anything down.
Is my marginal rate the same as my tax band?
Usually, but not always. National insurance, student loan repayments and any tapered allowance all add to the rate on the next pound. Add them up and you have your real marginal rate.
Why do pension contributions look cheap at a higher band?
Because they come off the top slice of income, the one taxed at your marginal rate. A contribution of 100 costs someone at forty percent only 60 of take-home pay.

Anita Desai

Twelve years in pensions administration, now writing Atlas full time. Believes every money question has a worked example, and that most advice skips it.

All Posts →

Atlas

Money, explained slowly. Saving, investing, housing, tax, work, family, retirement and debt, one topic at a time.

Visit Site

One topic a week, by email

Every Atlas post, the morning it is published, with the worked example and nothing else.

You may also want to read